BREAKING

follow Us :
Search Here

The Gun Case of the Decade: Supreme Court to Test How Far Cabinet Can Reach

  • November 7, 2026
  • TSA News

The Gun Case of the Decade: Supreme Court to Test How Far Cabinet Can Reach

On Monday, Canada’s highest court takes up a fight that is about guns on its surface and about executive power underneath. On 9 and 10 November 2026 the Supreme Court of Canada hears four appeals against the May 2020 Order in Council that prohibited approximately 1,500 models of firearms. The Globe and Mail calls it the biggest hearing of the fall at the court. The hearing will be webcast live.

The case in brief

The appeals are heard together under court files 41858 to 41861. They are led by Generoux v. Attorney General of Canada, alongside cases brought by the Canadian Coalition for Firearm Rights, Doherty and Eichenberg. The appellants include licensed owners, hunters, sport shooters, clubs and businesses.

They challenge the May 2020 regulation, SOR/2020-96. They lost twice: the Federal Court dismissed their judicial review applications on October 30, 2023, and the Federal Court of Appeal dismissed their appeals on April 15, 2025. The Supreme Court granted leave to appeal on 19 March 2026.

What the justices must decide

The first question is one of authority. Per the court’s case summary, they must decide whether the regulation exceeds the Governor in Council’s power to prohibit firearms under s. 117.15 of the Criminal Code, read with the limit in s. 117.15(2). That subsection bars Cabinet from prohibiting something that is reasonable for hunting or sporting use in Canada. The second question is constitutional: whether the phrase “any variants or modified versions” infringes section 7 of the Charter.

The Canadian Coalition for Firearm Rights argues that the order exceeded the intended scope of the Governor in Council’s regulation-making power under the Criminal Code, bypassing Parliament. The federal government’s position is that the prohibited guns are assault-style weapons that have been used in mass shootings.

A list that kept growing

The stakes have risen since 2020. The original order covered about 1,500 makes and models. As of December 5, 2024, an additional 324 makes and models were added, bringing the total to over 2,500 prohibited firearms. A lawyer’s explainer notes that how a decision would affect the 2024 and 2025 additions depends on what the court decides and how the government responds. The amnesty for all three rounds is tied to the same appeals.

The amnesty clock

For owners, the practical issue is the amnesty. On June 9, 2026, Public Safety Canada extended the amnesty orders, with the change published in the Canada Gazette on June 17, 2026. The amnesty now expires 90 days after the Supreme Court of Canada rules. A decision is expected next year.

Owners therefore have options in the meantime. The compensation program’s declaration window has closed, though Public Safety Canada is still processing cases with technical issues. Owners can also permanently deactivate a firearm through an approved business, legally export it, or wait for the court’s ruling. One legal explainer notes that if the government wins on the 2020 regulation, those firearms stay prohibited and the amnesty still ends 90 days after the appeals conclude.

Why this is bigger than guns

Beyond firearms, the case tests a recurring question in Canadian public law: how much Parliament has delegated to Cabinet, and when a broad regulation becomes something only legislators should do. Critics of the order say Cabinet used a regulation to do what should have required a bill. Supporters say Parliament deliberately gave Cabinet the power to classify firearms as technology evolves.

The court has other heavy business too. The Globe reports November is shaping up to be particularly busy for the court, with a pile of pending judgments, including the landmark ruling in the Quebec secularism case. The firearms appeals sit alongside that docket.

What happens next

Don’t expect a ruling this week. After two days of argument, the justices will take the matter under reserve, as they usually do in complex constitutional appeals. A decision is expected in 2027.

Until then, owners of the prohibited guns live with uncertainty, police and public-safety officials wait to learn the limits of their toolkit, and Ottawa waits to learn whether the 2020 approach, which later governments extended twice, stands. Whatever the court decides, the reasoning will matter far beyond firearms, because it will set a marker for the scope of cabinet’s regulatory power for years.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search Post
Popular Posts
Twin Storms, One Coast: Cyclone Murasu Leaves Andhra Reeling Days After Arnab
Big Bets, Bigger Bills: Carney’s Budget Wagers $142 Billion on a Self-Reliant Economy
Ottawa Was at the Table: Stellantis Plant Sale Puts Carney’s “Betrayal” Charge Under the Microscope
Follow Us

Follow us on social media and never miss the latest updates, trending news, and exclusive stories.